Menu
USD
Open Monday - Saturday
Fast Shipping
Free Local Pickup
Custom Orders and B2B
ABOUT
HOURS
GIFT CARD
REWARDS
Menu
USD
My account
Wish List
0
Home
Featured Products
Easter Basket
Spring '25 Collection
General Store Finds
Hearth & Home
Candles
Milkhouse
Taper & Pillar Candles
Candle Holders
Flameless Candles
Bins & Buckets
Blankets & Pillows
Box + Block Signs
Cleaning
Laundry
Decorative Accessories
Florals & Stems
Greenery
Jars, Baskets, Storage
Magnet
Mud Pie Home
Photo Frames
Rugs
Summer Decor
Vases
Wall Art Decor & Signs
Kitchen & Table
Breadmaking and Sourdough
Cook Books
Cups
Freeze Dry
Ice Cream
Jars & Canisters
Kitchen Basics
Kitchen Textiles
Kitchen Tools
Nordicware
Pans
Preserving
Serveware
Towels
Charcuterie
Apparel
Bags & Totes
Bogg Brand
Scout Bags Brand
Backpacks & Duffels
Handbags & Clutches
Mens
Women
Children's Clothing
Local Apparel
Crewnecks & Sweatshirts
Flannel
T-shirts
Hat
Belt
Footwear
Winter Accessories
Life is Good Apparel
Simply Southern
Books & Games
Games
Puzzles
Board Games
Card Games
Children's Games
Book Lovers
Cooking Titles
Design & Home Titles
Gift Titles
Home
Inspirational Titles
Kid's Reading Titles
Outdoor Titles
Goods
Gourmet
Tea Time
Candy
Pantry
Popcorn
Drinks
Syrup
Soups
Seasonings/Sauces
BBQ Sauces
Stationary
Journals and Notebooks
Cards
Writing utensils
Stickers
Recipes
Art Supplies
Paper and Party
Wellness
Mens Apothecary
Lip Balm
Bath
First-Aid
This & That
Pet Accessories
Travel
Trinkets, Key Chains, Jewelry
Jewelry
Umbrella
Outdoor Gear
Camp
Grilling
Camp Chairs
Cast Iron & Open Fire
JetBoil
RV Accessories
Lighting
Flash Cooking
Sleep & Relax
Backpacking Food
Fishing
Gardening
Lakeside
Boating
Water and Pool
Outdoor Games & Sports
Pickleball
Sling Shots
Picnic
BareBones Living Tools
Gifts & Toys
Toys
Dress Up
LEGO
Farm Toys
Fidgets Toys
Kids Activity & Sticker
Putty & Play Dough
Pretend Play Toys
Ride On Toys
Toy Animal Figurines
Shooting Toys
Wooden Toys
Vintage Fisher Price
Melissa and Doug
Infant & Child
Plush
Nappanee Merch
Gift Registry
Neighbors Merch
INVENTORY SALE: UP TO 75% OFF
Home
/
Gifts & Toys
Gifts & Toys
Toys
Infant & Child
Plush
Categories
Gifts & Toys
Toys
Infant & Child
Plush
Price
Min
Max
Filters
Show:
6
12
24
36
48
Default
Most viewed
Newest products
Lowest price
Highest price
Name ascending
Name descending
Filters
Show more products
Showing
193
-
216
of 736
Little Fox - Boho Woodland
Foster a love for our planet, one bamboo piece at a time. Discover the joy of co...
$12.97
$12.97
Belle the Cow Teething Rattle
Ring my bell anytime, Belle Cow! Belle is the most beautiful cow for miles. She ...
$14.48
$14.48
Franny Flamingo Teething Rattle
Strike a pose! Stand on one toe! Franny Flamingo is ready to go!!
Shake it with...
$14.48
$14.48
Clyde the Pony Teething Rattle
What do you do when you need a ride? Hope on your buddy, the Pony named Clyde.
...
$14.48
$14.48
Bruce Lemur Teething Rattle
Hi-yah! Meet Bruce Lemur he has a yellow belt in karate but a black belt in cudd...
$14.48
$14.48
Belle Cow 14” Plush
Ring my bell anytime, Belle Cow! She enamors her fans with her dazzling smiles. ...
$21.98
$21.98
Cupcake the Unicorn 14” Plush
Cupcake the unicorn, what does she do? She makes magic when she plays with you.
...
$21.98
$21.98
Georgia Giraffe 14” Plush
Georgia Giraffe is reallllly tall, she like buying turtle-necks at the mall.
Th...
$21.98
$21.98
Benny Badger Knit Pal
Love them up, tuck them into a cozy crib, or pop them on a prime time nursery sh...
$39.98
$39.98
Wooden Bead Maze
Engage little ones with this eye-catching Classic Toy Bead Maze. The colorful to...
$42.98
$42.98
Pretend to Spend Wallet
$17.98
$17.98
Nesting & Sorting Barns & Animals
$32.98
$32.98
Double Sided Magnetic Tabletop Easel
$52.98
$52.98
Build Your Own Wooden Birdhouse
$16.98
$16.98
Fold & Go Stable
$69.98
$69.98
Turn & Tell Wooden Clock
$18.98
$18.98
Wooden Farm Train
$24.98
$24.98
Police Officer Role Play Costume Set
$37.98
$37.98
Doctor Role Play Costume Set
$37.98
$37.98
Knight Role Play Costume Set
$37.98
$37.98
Brianna 12” Doll - Mine to Love
$32.98
$32.98
Baby Food & Bottles Set - Mine to Love
$22.98
$22.98
Gabrielle 12” Doll - Mine to Love
$32.98
$32.98
Rainbow Mini Scratch Art Notes
$2.98
$2.98
Showing
193
-
216
of 736
Show more
Price
Min
Max
Apply
Close
© Copyright 2025 Neighbors Mercantile Co ®
Choose your language
English (US)
Choose your currency
$
USD
My account
Login
Forgot your password?
or
Create an account
Recently added
Total excl. tax
$0.00
View cart (0)
Proceed to checkout
0
Compare
Start comparison
Add to cart
This product has been added to your cart
Proceed to checkout
Continue shopping