Menu
USD
Open Monday - Saturday
Fast Shipping
Free Local Pickup
Custom Orders and B2B
ABOUT
HOURS
GIFT CARD
REWARDS
Menu
USD
My account
Wish List
0
Home
Featured
Spring '25 Collection
Easter Basket
General Store Finds
Hearth & Home
Candles
Milkhouse
Taper & Pillar Candles
Candle Holders
Flameless Candles
Old Line Candle Co
Bins & Buckets
Blankets & Pillows
Box + Block Signs
Cleaning
Laundry
Decorative Accessories
Florals & Stems
Greenery
Jars, Baskets, Storage
Magnet
Mud Pie Home
Photo Frames
Rugs
Summer Decor
Vases
Wall Art Decor & Signs
Kitchen & Table
Breadmaking and Sourdough
Charcuterie
Cook Books
Cups
Freeze Dry
Ice Cream
Jars & Canisters
Kitchen Basics
Kitchen Textiles
Kitchen Tools
Nordicware
Pans
Preserving
Serveware
Towels
Apparel
Bags & Totes
Bogg Brand
Scout Bags Brand
Backpacks & Duffels
Handbags & Clutches
Men
Women
Children
Local Apparel
Crewnecks & Sweatshirts
Flannel
T-shirts
Hat
Belt
Footwear
Winter Accessories
Life is Good Apparel
Simply Southern
Books, Games & Puzzles
Books
Book Lovers
Childrens
Cooking Titles
Design & Home Titles
Gift Titles
Home
Inspirational Titles
Outdoor Titles
Games
Board Games
Card Games
Children's Games
Puzzles
Misc
White Mountain
Goods
Gourmet
Tea Time
Candy
Pantry
Popcorn
Drinks
Syrup
Soups
Seasonings/Sauces
BBQ Sauces
Stationary
Journals & Notebooks
Cards
Writing utensils
Stickers
Recipes
Art Supplies
Paper and Party
Wellness
Mens Apothecary
Lip Balm
Bath
First-Aid
This & That
Travel
Key Chains
Jewelry
Umbrella
Outdoor Gear
Camp
Grilling
Camp Chairs
Cast Iron & Open Fire Cooking
JetBoil
RV Accessories
Lighting
Flash Cooking
Sleep & Relax
Backpacking Food
Fishing
Gardening
Lakeside
Boating
Water and Pool
Outdoor Games & Sports
Pickleball
Sling Shots
Picnic
BareBones Living Tools
Toys
Balls
Dress Up
Farm Toys
Fidget Toys
Infant
Kids Activity & Sticker
LEGO
Melissa and Doug
Misc
Plush
Putty & Play Dough
Ride On Toys
Shooting Toys
Toy Animal Figurines
Vintage Fisher Price
Wooden Toys
Nappanee Merch
Gift Registry
Neighbors Merch
INVENTORY SALE: UP TO 75% OFF
Home
Putty & Play Dough
Price
Min
Max
Filters
Show:
6
12
24
36
48
Default
Most viewed
Newest products
Lowest price
Highest price
Name ascending
Name descending
Filters
Acai Bowl 2” Mini Thinking Putty
This sparkly, purple putty is as vibrant as the real acai superfruit and packed ...
$3.98
$3.98
Baby Elephant Full Size Putty
Go on a safari with this cute and shimmering light green putty. Match up the bab...
$13.98
$13.98
Bounce Bot 2" Mini Tin
Bounce Bot Thinking Putty® is filled with glitter “gears” to sculpt, shape, and ...
$3.98
$3.98
Comic Book 4" Thinking Putty
Save the day with Comic Book Thinking Putty®! This super powered putty has all t...
$13.98
$13.98
Cotton Candy 2” Mini Thinking Putty
You usually must choose between a pink or blue cotton candy, but with Cotton Can...
$3.98
$3.98
Dolphin Dance 4” Thinking Putty
Bring out your playful side with Dolphin Dance Thinking Putty®! Stretch, squish,...
$13.98
$13.98
Eggcellent 4” Thinking Putty
This unique putty comes with a globby ball that you can play with on its own or ...
$13.98
$13.98
Falling Water Liquid Glass 4" Thinking Putty
Known to be magical, majestic, and relaxing, waterfalls are often found in the m...
$13.98
$13.98
Flower Power Vibes Scentsory Putty Tin
$6.98
$6.98
Full Size 4" Putty Dolphin Dance
Bring out your playful side with Dolphin Dance Thinking Putty®! Stretch, squish,...
$13.98
$13.98
Full Size 4" Putty Kawaii Cute
Kawaii Cute Thinking Putty® is so adorable, it can instantly turn your frown ups...
$13.98
$13.98
Futbol 2” Mini Thinking Putty
This clear putty is packed with black and white sequins, creating the look of a ...
$3.98
$3.98
Happy Earth 4" Magnetic Thinking Putty
You’ll be a happy camper knowing our Thinking Putty® tins are made of food grade...
$13.98
$13.98
Happy Pinch Me Therapy Dough 3 oz
Brighten your day with Happy Pinch Me Therapy Dough, a mood-boosting blend of jo...
$14.98
$14.98
Honey Hive 4" Thinking Putty
You’ll “bee” mesmerized by the energetic amber and glistening gold hues of Honey...
$13.98
$13.98
Jam Session Vibes Scentsory Putty Tin
$6.98
$6.98
Ketchup and Mustard 2” Mini Thinking Putty
Time to play with your food with a mini tin of Ketchup & Mustard Thinking Putty™...
$3.98
$3.98
Loot Box Trend 2” Mini Thinking Putty
It’s time to redeem your Loot Box Thinking Putty®! This glitter treasure chest w...
$3.98
$3.98
McSlime Slime Charmers
Time to pick up a quick bite of fun with Crazy Aaron's® Slime Charmers™ McSlime....
$10.98
$10.98
Melon Pinch Me Therapy Dough 3 oz
Return to summer with the refreshing aroma of juicy, fresh-picked melons. A deli...
$14.98
$14.98
Mermaid Magic Slime Charmers
Time to explore the world under the sea with Crazy Aaron's® Slime Charmers™ Merm...
$10.98
$10.98
Mermaid Tale 4" Thinking Putty
$13.98
$13.98
Mini Mini Mart Slime Charmers
Look no further, we got what you need with the new Crazy Aaron’s® Slime Charmers...
$10.98
$10.98
Mixed Emotions 4" Thinking Putty
$13.98
$13.98
Showing
1
-
24
of 39
Show more
Price
Min
Max
Apply
Close
© Copyright 2025 Neighbors Mercantile Co ®
Choose your language
English (US)
Choose your currency
$
USD
My account
Login
Forgot your password?
or
Create an account
Recently added
Total excl. tax
$0.00
View cart (0)
Proceed to checkout
0
Compare
Start comparison
Add to cart
This product has been added to your cart
Proceed to checkout
Continue shopping
By using our website, you agree to the use of cookies. These cookies help us understand how customers arrive at and use our site and help us make improvements.
Hide this message
More on cookies »