Home/Store/Kitchen & Table/Gourmet/Seasonings & Sauces
Add to Favorites
Captain Rodney's Hot Pepper Jelly
+6
+5
+4
+3
+2

Captain Rodney's Hot Pepper Jelly

Share
$11.98
Buy and save
Buy and earn $0.59 Loyalty for your next purchase
Loyalty is a discount program that lets you buy products and earn points to redeem on your next purchase. Your Loyalty balance is updated when you pay online or in-store. The Loyalty amount shown on this page can be recalculated at the checkout.
In stock
Product Details

The Original Private Reserve product, created for the Captain’s personal use! Captain Rodney now offers his Pepper Jelly for those who need a little more spice in their lives. The Captain’s Hot Pepper Jelly features the same recipe as our Original Pepper Jelly, but with more hot pepper, for a spicier pepper jelly experience. All-natural, made with only the finest ingredients including Jamaican Scotch Bonnets and locally grown bell peppers.

Ingredients: Pure Cane Sugar, Apple Cider Vinegar, Sweet Bell Peppers, Water, Fruit Pectin, Scotch Bonnet Peppers, Salt.

11.5 ounces

Show More
Captain Rodney's Hot Pepper Jelly
Share
You May Also Like
Blue Ribbon Competition Style BBQ Sauce
Blue Ribbon Competition Style BBQ Sauce
Blue Ribbon Competition Style BBQ Sauce
$9.98
Jim’s Smokin’ Que Special Reserve Butt Sauce
Jim’s Smokin’ Que Special Reserve Butt Sauce
Jim’s Smokin’ Que Special Reserve Butt Sauce
$9.98
Captain Rodney's Tennessee Whiskey BBQ Rub
Captain Rodney's Tennessee Whiskey BBQ Rub
Captain Rodney's Tennessee Whiskey BBQ Rub
$11.98
PS Seasoning The Tailgater - Ballpark Blend
PS Seasoning The Tailgater - Ballpark Blend
PS Seasoning The Tailgater - Ballpark Blend
$8.98
Captain Rodney's Spicy Peach BBQ Sauce
Captain Rodney's Spicy Peach BBQ Sauce
Captain Rodney's Spicy Peach BBQ Sauce
$16.98
  • Search Products
  • My Account
  • Track Orders
  • Favorites
  • Shopping Bag
  • Gift Cards
Powered by Lightspeed
Display prices in:USD
Skip to main content
Shop our Holiday Collection
Neighbors Mercantile
Menu
Gift Registry
Holiday Finds
Apparel & Accessories
Books
Hearth & Home
Kitchen & Table
Outdoors
Toys, Games, & Puzzles
Gift Cards
About Us
Catalog
Apparel & AccessoriesBooksHearth & HomeKitchen & TableOutdoorsToys, Games, & Puzzles
Helpful Links
Search ProductsAccountTrack OrdersShopping BagGift CardsReviewsPop Up & Vendor ApplicationRewards Program
About
Find Toys at Neighbors MercantileDiscover Neighbors Holiday Shopping at Neighbors Mercantile Shop Kitchen Tools at Neighbors Day Trip to NappaneeLearn More about Neighbors
Contact Us

151 E. Market St.

Nappanee, IN, US


Mon–Sat: 9:00 AM — 8:00 PM

Sun: Closed


+1-574-773-7039

Contact Us

Terms & ConditionsPrivacy PolicyPayment MethodsReturns PolicyReport Abuse

Copyright © 2026 Neighbors Mercantile Co ®

Powered by Lightspeed