Classic Toys

Home/Store/Toys, Games, & Puzzles/Classic Toys
Refine by
 

Filters

Clear all
Filters
Clear all
Price
 
Clear
Price
Clear
from
–
to
$0
$43
Search by phrase
 
Clear
Search by phrase
Clear
Keyword or phrase
Search by SKU
 
Clear
Search by SKU
Clear
SKU
Sort by
 
Sort by
Art Creativity Star Pin Art Game
Art Creativity Star Pin Art Game
Art Creativity Star Pin Art Game
$9.68
Cup and Ball
Cup and Ball
Cup and Ball
$4.98
Fisher-Price Cash Register
Fisher-Price Cash Register
Fisher-Price Cash Register
$35.98
Fisher-Price Chatter Phone
Fisher-Price Chatter Phone
Fisher-Price Chatter Phone
$19.98
Fisher-Price Pull A Tune Xylophone
Fisher-Price Pull A Tune Xylophone
Fisher-Price Pull A Tune Xylophone
$26.98
Fisher-Price TV Radio
Fisher-Price TV Radio
Fisher-Price TV Radio
$21.98
Gumball Bank
Gumball Bank
Gumball Bank
$14.98
Hand Buzzer
Hand Buzzer
Hand Buzzer
$5.98
Hi-Score Pinball
Hi-Score Pinball
Hi-Score Pinball
$9.98
Jetfire Glider Twin Pack
Jetfire Glider Twin Pack
Jetfire Glider Twin Pack
$7.98
Jump Rope Set of 2
Jump Rope Set of 2
Jump Rope Set of 2
$2.48
Junior Tool Kit
Junior Tool Kit
Junior Tool Kit
$19.98
Little Box of Marbles
Little Box of Marbles
Little Box of Marbles
$6.98
Magnetic Gyro Wheel
Magnetic Gyro Wheel
Magnetic Gyro Wheel
$8.98
Melissa & Doug Deluxe Pounding Bench with colorful pegs and smiling faces on a sturdy wooden base with red legs.
Melissa & Doug Deluxe Pounding Bench
Melissa & Doug Deluxe Pounding Bench
$21.98
Melissa & Doug First Bead Maze toy with colorful beads and suction cup base, showcasing 18 multi-shaped beads and wire pathways.
Melissa & Doug First Bead Maze
Melissa & Doug First Bead Maze
$17.98
Melissa & Doug Giddy Buggy Bowling Set with six colorful pins and a red ball, featuring smiling caterpillar faces and striped bodies.
Melissa & Doug Giddy Buggy Bowling Set
Melissa & Doug Giddy Buggy Bowling Set
$22.98
Melissa & Doug Primary Lacing Beads, colorful wooden beads in six vibrant colors, thirty hand-painted beads, and two laces.
Melissa & Doug Primary Lacing Beads
Melissa & Doug Primary Lacing Beads
$16.98
Melissa & Doug Rainbow Stacker, a colorful wooden toy with 8 smooth, easy-grasp pieces in rainbow colors on a solid-wood base.
Melissa & Doug Rainbow Stacker
Melissa & Doug Rainbow Stacker
$10.98
Melissa & Doug Shape Sorting Cube with 12 chunky colorful shapes and natural-finish hardwood cube for kids to learn and play.
Melissa & Doug Shape Sorting Cube
Melissa & Doug Shape Sorting Cube
$20.98
Melissa & Doug Take-Along Tool Kit with wooden nails, screws, boards, hammer, wrench, and screwdriver, colorful tools for children.
Melissa & Doug Take-Along Tool Kit
Melissa & Doug Take-Along Tool Kit
$19.98
Melissa & Doug Wooden Alphabet Magnets, colorful letters in a wooden box, perfect for learning and creativity, for kids.
Melissa & Doug Wooden Alphabet Magnets
Melissa & Doug Wooden Alphabet Magnets
$17.98
Melissa & Doug Wooden Bead Maze with colorful beads and wires on a wooden base with multiple pathways and shapes.
Melissa & Doug Wooden Bead Maze
Melissa & Doug Wooden Bead Maze
$42.98
Metallic Muddle Puzzle
Metallic Muddle Puzzle
Metallic Muddle Puzzle
$7.98
Metallic Muddle Puzzle Keyring
Metallic Muddle Puzzle Keyring
Metallic Muddle Puzzle Keyring
$2.98
Music Maker
Music Maker
Music Maker
$7.98
Neato! Spy Eye-Gag Gift Retro
Neato! Spy Eye-Gag Gift Retro
Neato! Spy Eye-Gag Gift Retro
$2.98
Newtons Cradle
Newtons Cradle
Newtons Cradle
$15.98
Original Wooden Kazoo
Original Wooden Kazoo
Original Wooden Kazoo
$8.98
Pin Art
Pin Art
Pin Art
$25.98
Poly Glider
Poly Glider
Poly Glider
$0.98
Rainbow Magic Classic Slinky
Rainbow Magic Classic Slinky
Rainbow Magic Classic Slinky
$1.98
Retro Juggling Ball - Assorted
Retro Juggling Ball - Assorted
Retro Juggling Ball - Assorted
$9.98
Retro Jump Rope
Retro Jump Rope
Retro Jump Rope
$3.48
Rocket Balloon w/Pump
Rocket Balloon w/Pump
Rocket Balloon w/Pump
$11.98
Steel Safe w/Alarm
Steel Safe w/Alarm
Steel Safe w/Alarm
$31.98
Toy Tin - Marbles
Toy Tin - Marbles
Toy Tin - Marbles
$9.98
Viewmaster Boxed Set
Viewmaster Boxed Set
Viewmaster Boxed Set
$19.98
Whoopee Cushion
Whoopee Cushion
Whoopee Cushion
$2.48
Wooden Sky-Top - Rainbow
Wooden Sky-Top - Rainbow
Wooden Sky-Top - Rainbow
$5.48
Wooden Whizzer
Wooden Whizzer
Wooden Whizzer
$8.48
World's Smallest Glow Worm
World's Smallest Glow Worm
World's Smallest Glow Worm
$6.98
World's Smallest Hot Wheels Viewmaster
World's Smallest Hot Wheels Viewmaster
World's Smallest Hot Wheels Viewmaster
$7.98
World's Smallest Mr Potato Head
World's Smallest Mr Potato Head
World's Smallest Mr Potato Head
$6.98
World's Smallest Pogo Ball
World's Smallest Pogo Ball
World's Smallest Pogo Ball
$5.98
World's Smallest Polaroid Go Camera
World's Smallest Polaroid Go Camera
World's Smallest Polaroid Go Camera
$6.98
World's Smallest Slinky Dog
World's Smallest Slinky Dog
World's Smallest Slinky Dog
$7.98
World's Smallest Tech Deck Series
World's Smallest Tech Deck Series
World's Smallest Tech Deck Series
$5.98
World’s Smallest Duncan Butterfly Yo Yo
World’s Smallest Duncan Butterfly Yo Yo
World’s Smallest Duncan Butterfly Yo Yo
$5.98
  • Search Products
  • My Account
  • Track Orders
  • Favorites
  • Shopping Bag
  • Gift Cards
Powered by Lightspeed
Display prices in:USD
Skip to main content
Shop our Holiday Collection
Neighbors Mercantile
Menu
Gift Registry
Holiday Finds
Apparel & Accessories
Books
Hearth & Home
Kitchen & Table
Outdoors
Toys, Games, & Puzzles
Gift Cards
About Us
Catalog
Apparel & AccessoriesBooksHearth & HomeKitchen & TableOutdoorsToys, Games, & Puzzles
Helpful Links
Search ProductsAccountTrack OrdersShopping BagGift CardsReviewsPop Up & Vendor ApplicationRewards Program
About
Find Toys at Neighbors MercantileDiscover Neighbors Holiday Shopping at Neighbors Mercantile Shop Kitchen Tools at Neighbors Day Trip to NappaneeLearn More about Neighbors
Contact Us

151 E. Market St.

Nappanee, IN, US


Mon–Sat: 9:00 AM — 8:00 PM

Sun: Closed


+1-574-773-7039

Contact Us

Terms & ConditionsPrivacy PolicyPayment MethodsReturns PolicyReport Abuse

Copyright © 2026 Neighbors Mercantile Co ®

Powered by Lightspeed