Sep 4, 2025

Award-Winning Slice of Home: Laramie’s Apple Crumb Pie Recipe

Fall in Nappanee means one thing - APPLES! 🍎 From September 18-20, our town will be bustling with visitors for the Nappanee Apple Festival, a celebration of community, heritage, and of course, all things apple. Here at Neighbors Mercantile, we wanted to join in the fun by sharing a sweet slice of local history.


That slice comes from our very own General Manager, Laramie, who knows a thing or two about baking. Back in high school, she entered the Elkhart County 4-H Fair with an apple pie she perfected alongside her mother, Marla. Spoiler alert: it didn't just turn heads - it won awards!


More Than Just Animals: The 4-H Connection

When most people think of the Elkhart County 4-H Fair, animals are usually the first thing that comes to mind - cows, pigs, horses, and chickens. But the 4-H Fair is so much more than that. The Foods Project, which Laramie participated in, gives young people the chance to explore cooking, baking, food preservation, and nutrition.

Each year, the 4-H fair showcases hundreds of non-livestock projects - everything from photography to sewing to woodworking. It's a chance for kids to learn practical skills, gain confidence, and maybe even discover a lifelong passion. For Laramie, it was baking.

That's where Laramie found her stride. She and her mom spent weeks experimenting- testing white sugar vs. brown sugar, comparing tart vs. sweet apples, and carefully deciding what would make the perfect pie. Each batch was tasted side-by-side until they landed on the winning combination.


Two women holding pie pans containing pie crusts. Two women holding pie pans containing pie crusts.

A Slice of Festival History

Since its humble beginnings in 1975, the Nappanee Apple Festival has grown into one of Indiana's largest and most beloved festivals, drawing over 80,000 visitors each year. What started as a community event to celebrate the apple harvest has blossomed into a three-day tradition packed with fun for all ages.


The festival is home to the world-famous seven-foot apple pie, weighing nearly 600 pounds-a true centerpiece of the weekend. Visitors also enjoy live entertainment across multiple stages, a giant parade (complete with a military flyover), carnival rides, more than 150 craft and food vendors, and of course, plenty of apple treats-from fritters to dumplings to cider.


It’s more than just a festival; it’s a celebration of small-town pride, heritage, and togetherness.


Sliced applies in pie crust on wooden surface.Sliced applies in pie crust on wooden surface.

Laramie's Award-Winning Apple Pie Recipe

And now, because we couldn't just talk about apple pie without sharing, here's the recipe that started it all - Laramie's Award-Winning Apple Pie!


INGREDIENTS


For the Crust (makes 4 crusts):


3 cups all-purpose flour


1 cup shortening (such as Crisco)


1 teaspoon salt


1/3 cup vegetable oil


1/3 cup water


1/3 cup milk


For the Filling:


3 large tart apples (Granny Smith recommended), peeled and cored


1/2 cup granulated sugar


1 teaspoon cinnamon

For the Crumble Topping:


1/3 cup cold unsalted butter, cubed


1/2 cup granulated sugar


3/4 cup all-purpose flour


INSTRUCTIONS


Prepare the Crust


In a large mixing bowl, combine flour, shortening, and salt.


In a separate bowl, whisk together the oil, water, and milk.


Add the wet ingredients to the dry ingredients. Mix with a fork until the dough just comes together.


Roll out the portion of the dough on a lightly floured surface to fit a 9-inch pie pan. (The recipe makes four crusts; wrap and refrigerate the extra portions for later use.)


Carefully transfer the rolled dough into the pie pan. Trim excess dough and crimp the edges.


Prepare the Filling


Slice the peeled and cored apples thinly, then arrange them evenly inside the prepared pie crust.


In a small bowl, mix together the sugar and cinnamon. Sprinkle evenly over the apples.

Prepare the Crumble Topping


In a medium bowl, cut the butter into the flour and sugar using a pastry cutter or your fingers until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.


Sprinkle the crumble mixture evenly over the apples.


Bake the Pie


Preheat oven to 425°F (220°C).


Bake the pie for 10 minutes.


Reduce the oven temperature to 350°F (175°C) and continue baking for 40 minutes, or until the crust is golden and the filling is bubbly.


Allow to cool slightly before slicing. Serve warm, optionally with vanilla ice cream.


In Closing

This September, as you enjoy the Nappanee Apple Festival, we hope you’ll feel the heart behind every bite—whether it’s Laramie’s award-winning pie or that gigantic communal treat fresh from the festival oven. Because in Nappanee, apple pie isn’t just dessert—it’s tradition, family, and the warmest slice of home.

More Posts

<p>Holidays at Home: Christmas 2026 Trends We're Loving</p><p>Holidays at Home: Christmas 2026 Trends We're Loving</p>

Holidays at Home: Christmas 2026 Trends We're Loving

There's something special about decorating for Christmas. Pulling out the ornaments you've collected over the years, finding the perfect spot for your favorite wreath, and adding those little touches that make your home feel ready for the holidays.


At Neighbors Mercantile, Christmas planning starts long before the first snowflake falls. As we've been selecting our collections for 2026, we've noticed a few decorating trends that have us especially excited for the season ahead.


This year, we're seeing a beautiful mix of handmade charm, nostalgic traditions, rich colors, and timeless pieces. Some styles feel like Christmas at Grandma's house, while others bring a more polished, elegant touch. And the best part? You don't have to choose just one.


Here are four Christmas decorating trends we're loving for 2026.

<p>Putting Up the Harvest: A Beginner’s Guide to Canning &amp; Preserving</p><p>Putting Up the Harvest: A Beginner’s Guide to Canning &amp; Preserving</p>

Putting Up the Harvest: A Beginner’s Guide to Canning & Preserving

There’s something special about this time of year. Gardens are overflowing, farmers market baskets are full, and suddenly you have more cucumbers, tomatoes, sweet corn, and green beans than you know what to do with.


That’s where preserving comes in.

For generations, families have found ways to make the summer harvest last a little longer. And while canning may be the first thing that comes to mind, you can also freeze, dry, pickle, ferment, and even freeze-dry your favorite foods.


The best part? You don't need to be an expert—or have a kitchen full of equipment—to get started.


Nordic Ware vs USA Pan: What’s Right For You?Nordic Ware vs USA Pan: What’s Right For You?
Nordic Ware vs USA Pan: What’s Right For You?

When it comes to reliable, American-made bakeware, two names consistently rise to the top: Nordic Ware and USA Pan. Both brands are known for durability, performance, and thoughtful design—but they take very different approaches to materials and baking styles. Whether you’re a casual home baker or a detail-oriented cake enthusiast, choosing between them comes down to how (and what) you love to bake. Here’s what you need to know before you decide.

<p>Treasure Hunting in Nappanee? Make Neighbors Mercantile One of Your First Stops</p><p>Treasure Hunting in Nappanee? Make Neighbors Mercantile One of Your First Stops</p>

Treasure Hunting in Nappanee? Make Neighbors Mercantile One of Your First Stops

If you're planning to visit Nappanee for the annual Experience Nappanee celebration, be sure to add Neighbors Mercantile to your garage sale route.


From Thursday, July 9 through Saturday, July 11, we'll be joining the city-wide Embrace the Pace Garage Sales with a special outdoor garage sale featuring hundreds of deeply discounted items. The city-wide garage sales are part of the larger Experience Nappanee 2026 celebration, a weekend filled with local shopping, live music, family activities, food trucks, and community events throughout downtown.


Bringing Spring to Life with Real Touch GreeneryBringing Spring to Life with Real Touch Greenery
Bringing Spring to Life with Real Touch Greenery

There’s something about spring that makes us crave fresh starts—open windows, lighter spaces, and a little more life in every corner of our homes. Our Spring Real Touch Greenery collection was curated to do just that: bring the beauty of the outdoors in, without the upkeep.


Designed to look and feel incredibly lifelike, real touch greenery offers the softness and texture of fresh stems with the ease of everyday styling—no watering required. Whether you're refreshing your home for the season or preparing for special gatherings, these pieces make it simple to create a space that feels alive, welcoming, and effortlessly styled.


Stronger Days on the Line: Meet Poly-Grip ClothespinsStronger Days on the Line: Meet Poly-Grip Clothespins
Stronger Days on the Line: Meet Poly-Grip Clothespins

At Neighbors Mercantile, we believe everyday tools should work as hard as you do. Whether you’re embracing a slower, more sustainable rhythm or simply tired of flimsy clothespins that snap, twist, and fail when you need them most—there’s a better way to hang your laundry.


Enter Poly-Grip Clothespins: thoughtfully designed, American-made, and built to last.


Sourdough at Home: A Beginner’s Guide from Neighbors MercantileSourdough at Home: A Beginner’s Guide from Neighbors Mercantile
Sourdough at Home: A Beginner’s Guide from Neighbors Mercantile

There’s something special about sourdough. The smell of a loaf baking in the oven, the crackle of a golden crust, the tangy flavor that only time and fermentation can create—it’s bread the way it was meant to be.


At Neighbors Mercantile, we believe sourdough isn’t just food. It’s a craft, a rhythm, and a connection to simpler, slower living. Whether you’re brand new or ready to try again, this guide will walk you through the why, the how, and the what you need to get started.


<p>Timeless Toys: Built for Play Today and Memories Tomorrow</p><p>Timeless Toys: Built for Play Today and Memories Tomorrow</p>

Timeless Toys: Built for Play Today and Memories Tomorrow

At Neighbors Mercantile, we believe the best toys aren’t the ones that light up, beep, or need batteries—they’re the ones that spark imagination, stand the test of time, and get passed from one set of small hands to the next.


There’s something special about a toy that doesn’t just belong to one child, but becomes part of a family story. The scuffed wheels, the worn paint, the tiny fingerprints—those are signs of a childhood well played. That’s why we’re proud to offer a collection of timeless, classic toys designed to last for years, even generations.


Bring the Beat Outdoors — Meet Turtlebox Audio at Neighbors MercantileBring the Beat Outdoors — Meet Turtlebox Audio at Neighbors Mercantile
Bring the Beat Outdoors — Meet Turtlebox Audio at Neighbors Mercantile

At Neighbors Mercantile, we’re all about gear that keeps life loud, rugged, and ready for adventure — and that’s exactly why we carry Turtlebox Audio speakers. These aren’t your average Bluetooth boxes — they’re engineered for real outdoor use: rain, dirt, beach days, campfires, tailgates… you name it. Born from a garage idea to build the ultimate outdoor speaker, Turtlebox Audio has carved a niche as best-in-class for rugged performance and bold sound that travels with you.


Whether you’re chilling at the campsite or powering the party on your patio, we’ve got Turtlebox speakers ready to rock your soundtrack.