Plush Toys

Home/Store/Toys, Games, & Puzzles/Plush Toys
Refine by
 

Filters

Clear all
Filters
Clear all
Price
 
Clear
Price
Clear
from
–
to
$7
$65
Search by phrase
 
Clear
Search by phrase
Clear
Keyword or phrase
Search by SKU
 
Clear
Search by SKU
Clear
SKU
Sort by
 
Sort by
Again Friends Sprouts Cow – 6″
Again Friends Sprouts Cow – 6″
Again Friends Sprouts Cow – 6″
$15.98
Again Friends Sprouts Elephant – 6″
Again Friends Sprouts Elephant – 6″
Again Friends Sprouts Elephant – 6″
$15.98
Again Friends Sprouts Lamb – 6″
Again Friends Sprouts Lamb – 6″
Again Friends Sprouts Lamb – 6″
$15.98
Again Friends Sprouts Monkey – 6″
Again Friends Sprouts Monkey – 6″
Again Friends Sprouts Monkey – 6″
$15.98
Again Friends Sprouts Moose – 6″
Again Friends Sprouts Moose – 6″
Again Friends Sprouts Moose – 6″
$15.98
Again Friends Sprouts Pig – 6″
Again Friends Sprouts Pig – 6″
Again Friends Sprouts Pig – 6″
$15.98
Again Friends Sprouts Puppy – 6″
Again Friends Sprouts Puppy – 6″
Again Friends Sprouts Puppy – 6″
$15.98
Again Friends Sprouts Teddy – 6″
Again Friends Sprouts Teddy – 6″
Again Friends Sprouts Teddy – 6″
$15.98
Ballerina Mouse 14” Plush Toy
Ballerina Mouse 14” Plush Toy
Ballerina Mouse 14” Plush Toy
$23.98
Blush Putty Baby Sloth
Blush Putty Baby Sloth
Blush Putty Baby Sloth
$14.98
Blush Putty Kitty
Blush Putty Kitty
Blush Putty Kitty
$27.98
Blush Putty Unicorn 13”
Blush Putty Unicorn 13”
Blush Putty Unicorn 13”
$25.98
Blush Putty Unicorn Small 10”
Blush Putty Unicorn Small 10”
Blush Putty Unicorn Small 10”
$19.98
Boxer the Dog 14” Plush Toy
Boxer the Dog 14” Plush Toy
Boxer the Dog 14” Plush Toy
$23.98
Bunny Lovey White
Bunny Lovey White
Bunny Lovey White
$21.98
Cecily G 12” Soft Toy
Cecily G 12” Soft Toy
Cecily G 12” Soft Toy
$17.48
Cooper Putty Dog
Cooper Putty Dog
Cooper Putty Dog
$27.98
Coral Putty Fox
Coral Putty Fox
Coral Putty Fox
$25.98
Cotton Knit Pillow with Unicorn 12"
Cotton Knit Pillow with Unicorn 12"
Cotton Knit Pillow with Unicorn 12"
$14.98
Cream Putty Unicorn 13”
Cream Putty Unicorn 13”
Cream Putty Unicorn 13”
$27.98
Cream Putty Unicorn Small 10”
Cream Putty Unicorn Small 10”
Cream Putty Unicorn Small 10”
$19.98
Cupcake the Unicorn 14” Plush
Cupcake the Unicorn 14” Plush
Cupcake the Unicorn 14” Plush
$23.98
Easy Ride ‘Um Appaloosa Horse
Easy Ride ‘Um Appaloosa Horse
Easy Ride ‘Um Appaloosa Horse
$21.98
Easy Ride ‘Um Black Horse
Easy Ride ‘Um Black Horse
Easy Ride ‘Um Black Horse
$29.98
Easy Ride ‘Um Brown Horse
Easy Ride ‘Um Brown Horse
Easy Ride ‘Um Brown Horse
$29.98
Fabfuzz Pig Hamlet
Fabfuzz Pig Hamlet
Fabfuzz Pig Hamlet
$23.98
Fabfuzz Pig Peaches
Fabfuzz Pig Peaches
Fabfuzz Pig Peaches
$23.98
Fabfuzz Pig Pepper
Fabfuzz Pig Pepper
Fabfuzz Pig Pepper
$23.98
Fancy Prancer Unicorn
Fancy Prancer Unicorn
Fancy Prancer Unicorn
$27.98
Frenchy Fox 14” Plush Toy
Frenchy Fox 14” Plush Toy
Frenchy Fox 14” Plush Toy
$23.98
George Giraffe 14” Plush Toy
George Giraffe 14” Plush Toy
George Giraffe 14” Plush Toy
$23.98
Georgia Giraffe 14” Plush
Georgia Giraffe 14” Plush
Georgia Giraffe 14” Plush
$23.98
Giddy Up Pony Character Blanket
Giddy Up Pony Character Blanket
Giddy Up Pony Character Blanket
$21.98
Giddy Up Pony Crinkle Teether
Giddy Up Pony Crinkle Teether
Giddy Up Pony Crinkle Teether
$12.98
Giddy Up Pony Soft Toy
Giddy Up Pony Soft Toy
Giddy Up Pony Soft Toy
$24.98
Giddy Up Pony Teether Rattle
Giddy Up Pony Teether Rattle
Giddy Up Pony Teether Rattle
$11.98
Grey Putty Sloth
Grey Putty Sloth
Grey Putty Sloth
$27.98
Jesus Doll
Jesus Doll
Jesus Doll
$27.48
Kaylee Putty Kitten
Kaylee Putty Kitten
Kaylee Putty Kitten
$27.98
Leota Doll - Black Hair
Leota Doll - Black Hair
Leota Doll - Black Hair
$22.98
Little Plush Bunny - Wildflower Picnic
Little Plush Bunny - Wildflower Picnic
Little Plush Bunny - Wildflower Picnic
$29.98
Llama Llama Large Stuffed Toy
Llama Llama Large Stuffed Toy
Llama Llama Large Stuffed Toy
$15.98
Lovey Nursery Putty Blush Kitty
Lovey Nursery Putty Blush Kitty
Lovey Nursery Putty Blush Kitty
$16.98
Mama Lamb & Baby
Mama Lamb & Baby
Mama Lamb & Baby
$25.98
Marshmallow Junior Clyde Cow
Marshmallow Junior Clyde Cow
Marshmallow Junior Clyde Cow
$18.98
Marshmallow Junior Dragon
Marshmallow Junior Dragon
Marshmallow Junior Dragon
$18.98
Marshmallow Junior Elephant
Marshmallow Junior Elephant
Marshmallow Junior Elephant
$18.98
Marshmallow Junior Gator
Marshmallow Junior Gator
Marshmallow Junior Gator
$18.98
Marshmallow Junior Giraffe
Marshmallow Junior Giraffe
Marshmallow Junior Giraffe
$18.98
Marshmallow Junior Hagrid Highland Cow
Marshmallow Junior Hagrid Highland Cow
Marshmallow Junior Hagrid Highland Cow
$18.98
Marshmallow Junior Honey Highland Cow
Marshmallow Junior Honey Highland Cow
Marshmallow Junior Honey Highland Cow
$15.98
Marshmallow Junior Maximus Monster
Marshmallow Junior Maximus Monster
Marshmallow Junior Maximus Monster
$18.98
Marshmallow Junior Monkey
Marshmallow Junior Monkey
Marshmallow Junior Monkey
$18.98
Marshmallow Junior Moose
Marshmallow Junior Moose
Marshmallow Junior Moose
$18.98
Marshmallow Junior Puppy
Marshmallow Junior Puppy
Marshmallow Junior Puppy
$18.98
Marshmallow Junior Sloth
Marshmallow Junior Sloth
Marshmallow Junior Sloth
$18.98
Marshmallow Junior Stegosaurus
Marshmallow Junior Stegosaurus
Marshmallow Junior Stegosaurus
$18.98
Marshmallow Junior Tiger
Marshmallow Junior Tiger
Marshmallow Junior Tiger
$18.98
Marshmallow Reggie Puppy – 13″
Marshmallow Reggie Puppy – 13″
Marshmallow Reggie Puppy – 13″
$21.98
Marty the Bison Stuffed Animal
Marty the Bison Stuffed Animal
Marty the Bison Stuffed Animal
$13.98
1 - 60 of 93 items
Prev
12
Next
  • Search Products
  • My Account
  • Track Orders
  • Favorites
  • Shopping Bag
  • Gift Cards
Powered by Lightspeed
Display prices in:USD
Skip to main content
Shop our Holiday Collection
Neighbors Mercantile
Menu
Gift Registry
Holiday Finds
Apparel & Accessories
Books
Hearth & Home
Kitchen & Table
Outdoors
Toys, Games, & Puzzles
Gift Cards
About Us
Catalog
Apparel & AccessoriesBooksHearth & HomeKitchen & TableOutdoorsToys, Games, & Puzzles
Helpful Links
Search ProductsAccountTrack OrdersShopping BagGift CardsReviewsPop Up & Vendor ApplicationRewards Program
About
Find Toys at Neighbors MercantileDiscover Neighbors Holiday Shopping at Neighbors Mercantile Shop Kitchen Tools at Neighbors Day Trip to NappaneeLearn More about Neighbors
Contact Us

151 E. Market St.

Nappanee, IN, US


Mon–Sat: 9:00 AM — 8:00 PM

Sun: Closed


+1-574-773-7039

Contact Us

Terms & ConditionsPrivacy PolicyPayment MethodsReturns PolicyReport Abuse

Copyright © 2026 Neighbors Mercantile Co ®

Powered by Lightspeed