Stocking Stuffers

Home/Store/Seasonal/Christmas/Stocking Stuffers

Little Gifts, Big Christmas Smiles

Sometimes the smallest gifts bring the biggest smiles! Fill their stockings with playful surprises, thoughtful little treasures, fun gifts, and charming finds for all ages. Our Stocking Stuffers Collection makes it easy to find those extra-special goodies that make Christmas morning even more memorable.

Refine by
 

Filters

Clear all
Filters
Clear all
Price
 
Clear
Price
Clear
from
–
to
$1
$14
Search by phrase
 
Clear
Search by phrase
Clear
Keyword or phrase
Search by SKU
 
Clear
Search by SKU
Clear
SKU
Sort by
 
Sort by
*Batwheels Adhesive Bandages 14ct
*Batwheels Adhesive Bandages 14ct
*Batwheels Adhesive Bandages 14ct
$1.28
*Bluey 2Pk Molded Lip Balm Ni
*Bluey 2Pk Molded Lip Balm Ni
*Bluey 2Pk Molded Lip Balm Ni
$3.98
Bluey Lip Gloss Keychain Ni
Bluey Lip Gloss Keychain Ni
Bluey Lip Gloss Keychain Ni
$3.98
Boxing Reindeer Pen
Boxing Reindeer Pen
Boxing Reindeer Pen
$13.98
Disney Princess Royal Nail Set Ni
Disney Princess Royal Nail Set Ni
Disney Princess Royal Nail Set Ni
$4.18
Disney Toy Story 5 Lip Gloss Key Chain Buzz Ni
Disney Toy Story 5 Lip Gloss Key Chain Buzz Ni
Disney Toy Story 5 Lip Gloss Key Chain Buzz Ni
$3.98
Disney Toy Story 5 Lip Gloss Key Chain Jessie Ni
Disney Toy Story 5 Lip Gloss Key Chain Jessie Ni
Disney Toy Story 5 Lip Gloss Key Chain Jessie Ni
$3.98
Dumplings -Christmas Holiday Coconut Oil Mystery Squishy
Dumplings -Christmas Holiday Coconut Oil Mystery Squishy
Dumplings -Christmas Holiday Coconut Oil Mystery Squishy
$4.98
Gold Dig It Dino Dig
Gold Dig It Dino Dig
Gold Dig It Dino Dig
$3.98
Multi Color Christmas Theme Ballpoint Pen
Multi Color Christmas Theme Ballpoint Pen
Multi Color Christmas Theme Ballpoint Pen
$1.98
OMG Pop Fidgety - Holiday Pen Topper
OMG Pop Fidgety - Holiday Pen Topper
OMG Pop Fidgety - Holiday Pen Topper
$1.98
Toy Story 5 Jessie Lip Gloss & Balm Key Chain 2-Pack
Toy Story 5 Jessie Lip Gloss & Balm Key Chain 2-Pack
Toy Story 5 Jessie Lip Gloss & Balm Key Chain 2-Pack
$3.98
  • Search Products
  • My Account
  • Track Orders
  • Favorites
  • Shopping Bag
  • Gift Cards
Powered by Lightspeed
Display prices in:USD
Skip to main content
Shop our Holiday Collection
Neighbors Mercantile
Menu
Gift Registry
Holiday Finds
Apparel & Accessories
Books
Hearth & Home
Kitchen & Table
Outdoors
Toys, Games, & Puzzles
Gift Cards
About Us
Catalog
Apparel & AccessoriesBooksHearth & HomeKitchen & TableOutdoorsToys, Games, & Puzzles
Helpful Links
Search ProductsAccountTrack OrdersShopping BagGift CardsReviewsPop Up & Vendor ApplicationRewards Program
About
Find Toys at Neighbors MercantileDiscover Neighbors Holiday Shopping at Neighbors Mercantile Shop Kitchen Tools at Neighbors Day Trip to NappaneeLearn More about Neighbors
Contact Us

151 E. Market St.

Nappanee, IN, US


Mon–Sat: 9:00 AM — 8:00 PM

Sun: Closed


+1-574-773-7039

Contact Us

Terms & ConditionsPrivacy PolicyPayment MethodsReturns PolicyReport Abuse

Copyright © 2026 Neighbors Mercantile Co ®

Powered by Lightspeed